IPSE welcomes Loan Charge review but issues stark warning over IR35 endorsement

IPSE has welcomed the review into the Loan Charge by Sir Amyas Morse. Although IPSE would have liked to see Sir Amyas move to scrap the Loan Charge, it is good news that he has accepted most of its recommendations. These, in turn, have also been accepted by the government.


Most importantly, the government has said that loans that were taken out before December 2010 will be exempted from the review. It is estimated this will affect approximately 15,000 people. It has also said that loans that were taken out between 2010 and 2016 and declared will be exempted. It is estimated this will affect approximately 1,000 people.

The government has also said that people still affected by the Loan Charge will have the option to spread their repayments over three years. This will not only mitigate the abruptness of the repayments; it will also mean that an estimated 21,000 people will not be paying tax at an artificially higher rate.

Chris Bryce, CEO of IPSE said: “There are positives here for many of those affected by the Loan Charge. From the start, the Loan Charge has been a catastrophe for thousands of hard-working contractors who were wrongly told these schemes were legitimate and legal.

“Sir Amyas Morse’s report takes on most of IPSE’s recommendations to mitigate the damage done by the Loan Charge – most importantly, by exempting loans before 2010 and declared loans between 2010 and 2016. It will certainly be a happy Christmas for the contractors relieved of devastating charges by these announcements.

“It is also excellent news that the government has said that contractors can opt to spread repayments over three years. This will mitigate the shock of enormous payments and actually reduce the cost for many contractors.

“Positive as many of these announcements are, however, they cannot entirely reverse the damage of the Loan Charge. This ill-conceived policy did untold damage to thousands of lives across the country. Never again must the government launch retrospective, life-changing tax grabs of this kind.

“There is also an extremely disappointing endorsement of the changes to IR35 in the report. These changes will drive a whole new tranche of contractors back into the arms of the same snake-oil salesman who peddled these disguised remuneration schemes in the first place. IPSE explained this to Sir Amyas in person and in our written submission. That this report not only ignored this danger, but indeed actively supports the IR35 proposals is a major disappointment.”

Meet the author

IPSE logo 100x100px.png
IPSE is the leading association for contractors, consultants, interims, freelancers and the self-employed. We strive to bring our members the most comprehensive and useful range of information and services and all the latest news about what affects your business.

More on